Reader’s Choice: The Best Natural Dog Food Brands of 2023

Reader’s Choice: The Best Natural Dog Food Brands of 2023 As pet owners increasingly prioritize their furry companions’ well-being, the demand for natural dog food continues to rise. In 2023, the market offers various options,

Written by: Peyton Rivers

Published on: January 7, 2026

Reader’s Choice: The Best Natural Dog Food Brands of 2023

As pet owners increasingly prioritize their furry companions’ well-being, the demand for natural dog food continues to rise. In 2023, the market offers various options, making it essential for pet parents to choose wisely. Here are some of the best natural dog food brands that have earned a place in the hearts of dog owners and experts alike.

1. Orijen

Key Features:

  • High-protein recipes
  • Grain-free options
  • Fresh and raw ingredients

Orijen is celebrated for its biologically appropriate dog food, designed to mirror the natural diet of dogs. Their recipes typically feature 85% quality animal ingredients, including fresh or raw chicken, turkey, fish, and eggs. Orijen is particularly known for its low glycemic recipes that help maintain your dog’s healthy weight and energy levels.

Pros:

  • High protein content
  • Quality sourcing of ingredients
  • Variety of flavors

Cons:

  • Pricey compared to other brands
  • May be too rich for some dogs

2. Acana

Key Features:

  • Regionally sourced ingredients
  • Grain-free and whole prey recipes
  • Fresh meat inclusion

Acana, a sister company to Orijen, reflects a similar philosophy of fresh and natural ingredients. Their products often include animal protein, vegetables, and fruits from trusted regional farms. Acana dog food consists of wholesome grains like oats and barley in some recipes, catering to dogs with specific dietary needs.

Pros:

  • High-quality ingredients
  • Variety of flavors and formulas
  • Lower price point than Orijen

Cons:

  • Limited availability in some areas
  • Some dogs may prefer more flavor variety

3. Wellness CORE

Key Features:

  • High-protein, grain-free recipes
  • Balanced nutrition
  • Natural supplements for health

Wellness CORE has carved a niche in the natural dog food space by offering high-protein, grain-free diets infused with nutrients from real meat and healthy carbs. They focus on a holistic approach, incorporating antioxidants, omega fatty acids, probiotics, and glucosamine for joint health.

Pros:

  • Extensive product line for different dietary needs
  • Balanced nutrition tailored for active dogs
  • No artificial additives

Cons:

  • Some formulas use peas and lentils, which may not suit every dog
  • Smellier due to meat-based ingredients

4. Merrick

Key Features:

  • Real, whole foods
  • Grain-free options
  • Varied formats: kibble, wet food, and treats

Merrick is known for its commitment to using real, whole foods in its recipes. Their ingredients are sourced from local farmers in the USA, ensuring high-quality meat and produce. With an extensive range of flavors, including unique proteins like bison and lamb, Merrick makes it easy for pet parents to find something their dogs will love.

Pros:

  • Variety of protein sources
  • Options suitable for dogs with allergies
  • Nutrient-rich

Cons:

  • Recalls in the past have raised concerns
  • Availability may vary by region

5. Taste of the Wild

Key Features:

  • Grain-free recipes
  • Unique protein sources
  • Antioxidants and probiotics

Taste of the Wild offers high-quality, grain-free dog food inspired by the diets of wild canines. Their products feature real roasted meats as the first ingredient, supplemented with fruits and vegetables for balanced nutrition. The incorporation of probiotics aids digestion, making it a well-rounded option for many dogs.

Pros:

  • Affordable compared to premium brands
  • Wide range of flavors
  • Great digestibility

Cons:

  • Some dogs may experience allergies or sensitivities
  • Limited brand options for puppies

6. Canidae

Key Features:

  • Multi-protein formulas
  • Grain-free and limited ingredient diets
  • Customizable options for sensitivities

Canidae stands out with its tailored blends suited for dogs of all life stages. Their formulas contain whole foods and diverse protein options while focusing on fostering a healthy gut with probiotics. They also provide grain-free and limited ingredient diets, making them suitable for dogs with sensitivities.

Pros:

  • Versatile formulas for various dietary needs
  • Affordable price point for premium ingredients
  • Emphasis on wholesome nutrition

Cons:

  • Some formulas have higher carbohydrate content
  • Limited flavor variety in some lines

7. Nature’s Logic

Key Features:

  • Whole foods only
  • No synthetic vitamins
  • Focus on raw nutrition

Nature’s Logic prides itself on using 100% whole foods without synthetic additives, making it one of the most natural options available. Instead of artificial vitamins and minerals, they source nutrients from natural ingredients, catering to dogs’ ancestral dietary needs.

Pros:

  • Whole food focus
  • No synthetic additives
  • Transparent ingredient sourcing

Cons:

  • Higher price range
  • Availability issues might arise

8. Blue Buffalo

Key Features:

  • Variety of natural recipes
  • Life protection formula
  • Holistic approach to nutrition

Blue Buffalo is known for its “True Blue” promise to share nothing but the best ingredients. They incorporate unique life protection formulas with specific nutrients aimed at enhancing dogs’ vitality. Blue Buffalo’s diverse offerings, from grain-free to limited ingredient diets, accommodate many feeding preferences.

Pros:

  • Extensive range of products
  • Focus on holistic health
  • Quality ingredients from trusted sources

Cons:

  • Recalls in the past have created skepticism
  • High protein content may be overwhelming for some dogs

9. Solid Gold

Key Features:

  • Grain and gluten-free varieties
  • Probiotics for digestive health
  • Unique regional ingredients

Solid Gold has been in the dog food industry since 1974 and continues to innovate with recipes designed to promote health and vitality. Their formulas include unique ingredients and are often tailored to specific breeds or health issues, offering something for every dog.

Pros:

  • Pioneering natural ingredients
  • Unique flavors and formulations
  • Strong emphasis on gut health

Cons:

  • Higher price spectrum
  • Some dogs may not adapt to certain unique ingredients

10. Fromm Family Foods

Key Features:

  • High-quality, protein-rich recipes
  • Family-owned and operated
  • Range of specialty diets

Fromm Family Foods continues a longstanding tradition of quality dog food production with an emphasis on family values. Their recipes are crafted with care, using fresh ingredients and ensuring no fillers are added. Fromm offers various dietary options, including grain-inclusive and grain-free foods.

Pros:

  • Reputation for quality and consistency
  • Many unique recipes available
  • Family-operated business with strong ethics

Cons:

  • Premium price range
  • Limited availability in big-box stores

Each of these brands represents a commitment to providing natural, nutritious options for our canine companions. When selecting a dog food, consider your dog’s specific health needs, preferences, and dietary sensitivities. Ensuring your pet receives a balanced, high-quality diet can significantly impact their overall health and happiness in the long run.

Leave a Comment

Previous

affordable and eco-friendly dog collars that don’t compromise on style

Next

the rise of biodegradable dog collars: a pet trend for 2025